Thursday, January 15, 2015

A Trade War Over Cheap Chinese Solar Panels: Protecting American Ingenuity or Needlessly Raising Prices?

By Nick Lawton, Staff Attorney

On December 31, 2014, the U.S. Department of Commerce issued a preliminary finding that some Chinese solar panel manufacturers would become eligible for a reduction in trade tariffs. This finding is the latest volley in a trade war between the American and Chinese solar industries that began in 2011. SolarWorld Americas, the largest U.S. solar panel manufacturer, filed a trade case with the U.S. International Trade Administration, alleging that Chinese subsidies of solar panels were giving imported solar panels an unfair advantage and threatening the viability of the U.S. solar industry. SolarWorld won that round of the trade dispute. In May 2012, the Commerce Department initially imposed “anti-dumping” tariffs on imported Chinese solar panels. These “anti-dumping” tariffs aimed to offset the effect of Chinese subsidies that allowed the sale of Chinese solar panels in the United States at prices below actual manufacturing costs.

The next round of the dispute involved international industrial espionage, which led to the indictment of five Chinese military hackers and ignited a diplomatic conflict between the United States and China. According to the U.S. Department of Justice, at “about the same time” the Commerce Department imposed anti-dumping tariffs, a Chinese hacker stole “thousands of files” from SolarWorld, including confidential technical information and privileged attorney-client communications about the ongoing trade litigation. A spokesperson for the Chinese Foreign Ministry argued that the charges were “purely ungrounded and absurd” and based on “fabricated facts.” Additionally, the Washington Post reports that China noted similar NSA spying on Chinese companies, as revealed by leaks from Edward Snowden.

It is difficult to quantify the impacts of either espionage or allegedly unfair subsidies. A spokesperson for SolarWorld stated in May 2014 that there were “too many unknowables” preventing an exact estimate of the company’s financial losses from espionage. The New York Times quoted the president of a security technology and services company as stating that the value to Chinese companies “from these thefts of intellectual property is in the billions of dollars.”

As for the anti-dumping tariffs, the Commerce Department has attempted to impose different tariff rates on different manufacturers’ products to account for their actual behavior. Those tariff rates ranged as high as 165%, but the Commerce Department has lowered tariff rates for different manufacturers several times. For example, in July 2014, the tariff rate for Motech Industries was 44.18%, but the Commerce Department lowered that rate to 20.86% a month later. The latest reduction in tariff rates reflects a finding that actual solar panel “dumping,” or sale at prices below manufacturing costs, occurred at significantly lower rates than the Commerce Department had initially thought. The Commerce Department recommended lowering the tariff rate from 31% to roughly 18%. The President of SolarWorld, Mukesh Dulani, argues that the Commerce Department erred by failing to account for the behavior of the largest Chinese solar manufacturers. As a result, he argues that the proposed tariff rates “do not reflect the actual amount of dumping by Chinese producers.”

The trade dispute and its consequent tariffs have divided renewable energy advocates in the United States. Critics of the tariffs claim that they will result in higher prices for solar power, which runs counter to the U.S. goal of cost-competitive solar power and deters solar installations. Jigar Shah, president of the Coalition for Affordable Solar Energy, argues that the tariffs are “unproductive” and “will undercut the growth of American solar jobs and hurt our domestic solar industry.” The Solar Energy Industries Association (SEIA) contends that “the worsening solar dispute … threatens the future progress of solar energy in America.” SEIA’s opposition to the trade dispute led PetersenDean, a roofing and solar power company, to call for the resignation of SEIA’s president and entire board. Meanwhile, U.S. officials seem to side with SolarWorld. For example, U.S. Representative Rock Nolan (D.-MN) has stated that “the U.S. solar manufacturing industry has been devastated by China’s buildup of massive amounts of state-sponsored solar activity.” Senator Ron Wyden (D.-OR) has backed SolarWorld’s trade case since 2013 and testified in support of tariffs in December 2014. SolarWorld has won nine out of ten trade cases in this ongoing dispute.


The trade dispute over solar panels is almost certain to continue as both the United States and China seek to expand their solar industries. Both nations offer significant subsidies for solar power, including significant tax credits and grants for technological research and development. China has recently become one of the largest consumers of solar power and hosts many of the largest manufacturers of solar panels. The United States, meanwhile, is poised to become the world’s largest solar market, according to Jigar Shah. Because solar panels and other electrical components of solar arrays are globally traded commodities, the pace of the solar industry’s growth is likely to be influenced by ongoing trade disputes.

30 comments:

  1. Installing solar power is an excellent investment, both financially and environmentally. With the right Solar PV design and installation, you can slash your electricity bills and contribute to improving the environment at the same time. However, the rising demand for solar power means an increasing number of the number of unscrupulous salespeople who promise you low cost and equally low-performance models. Our systems have a 25 Year performance warranty backed by our 20+ years of customer service.

    ReplyDelete
  2. great pleasure reading your post.Its full of information I looking for and I love to post a comment that "The content of your post is awesome" Great work.
    solar customer

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks for sharing this great post. It’s very enlightening. I absolutely love to read informative stuff. Looking forward to find out more and acquire further knowledge from here! Cheers!
    solar panel installation

    ReplyDelete
  4. Solar Power. Below is a quick overview of solar power today. Below the overview, I've also added a number of additional solar power stories which are worth ... energy installs

    ReplyDelete
  5. It feels great to lower the cost of your electric bill and solar panels are perfect.
    Solar Installers Los Angeles

    ReplyDelete
  6. In my residence when I take bored, afterward I simply ON my PC and open YouTube web page to watch the YouTube video lessons.
    Solar contractor San Diego

    ReplyDelete
  7. Great post. Go green with solar power installation in Arizona. SolarEnergyXpert is a best solar company in Arizona, provides affordable and reliable solar panels. Visit us today.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi.....Moving to a huge and busy city costs a lot of money but you can reduce your expenses if you consider affordable foreclosed condo properties for sale. As far as foreclosed properties are concerned some of the better deals have been made through a short sale.Read more-newark property for sale

    ReplyDelete
  9. Have a nice day..How are you everybody...? Newark has plenty of areas you can escape to for total relaxation on your doorstep. There are the stunning cliffs that provide a wonderful walking experience; great for clearing the head and de stressing. Then there are the secluded Newark sandy beaches, coves, moorland, woodland and wildlife to explore. Your new home in Newark is not far from Exmoor and Dartmoor so you are never far away from nature.Take a look at-houses for sale newark

    ReplyDelete
  10. Hi.....Look at your home as a prospective purchaser would.If you are buying a replacement home then it shouldn't be hard to see your home as a buyer would. property for sale

    ReplyDelete

  11. Hi....Have a nice day. I would like to share with you a great news about property for sale..Look at your home as a prospective purchaser would.If you are buying a replacement home then it shouldn't be hard to see your home as a buyer would.See more at-property for sale

    ReplyDelete

  12. Hi admin,
    I have visited your blog,I have also a blog which is related with you, which is about Newark Investment Properties For Sale.
    There is a dearth of rental properties in the market right now and you can get high returns on your property investment if you plan to rent out the property you have bought.
    You should glean adequate information about the foreclosure procedure and find out the existing market rate of the foreclosed properties in the area you plan to buy a property.
    Newark Investment Properties For Sale

    Regards,
    fahiammahomead

    ReplyDelete
  13. Hello....Have a nice day. I would like to share with you a great news about property for sale..Almost every county government offers tax lien properties for sale, in one form or another. The government seizes properties when owners do not pay property, personal property or income taxes within a designated time, and public auctions are held as a means for the government to recoup the taxes owed.Read more at-property for sale

    ReplyDelete
  14. Dear,
    friends........
    I read your blog, its really awesome,
    I am seeing that you are selling home. I have also a site related to you.
    Everyone who intends to move out of the parent's home inevitably ends up asking herself an important question: "Should I rent a house or buy it?"

    houses to rent


    Your regards
    Alfaj Ripon

    ReplyDelete

  15. Hi admin,
    I really like it, I have also a blog which is related with you, which is about investment property in Newark.
    investment property in Newark will have either heard about or already realised the substantial profits which property investment can provide.
    There are also property investment companies offering investment properties
    with substantial discounts, due to their combined buying power.
    investment property in Newark

    Regards,
    foisalmahomed

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hi
    This guide has been prepared to assist sellers of houses to prepare their property for sale. the Real Estate markets around the world seem to be contracting so it is essential properties are well prepared and presented to maximise the sale price, Look at your home as a prospective purchaser would. If you are buying a replacement home then it shouldn't be hard to see your home as a buyer would. Read more at-Sell my newark House
    Thank You

    ReplyDelete
  17. Excellent and helpful post. Solar Panel are growing in popularity and it doesn't look like a trend that will be going away anytime soon.Adding solar panel to your home can make your home more green and it can also significantly reduce your utility bills, And you are also greatly helping our environment by producing clean energy from a renewable source.

    ReplyDelete
  18. Excellent blog, Thank you for sharing such a nice information
    Solar Panel

    ReplyDelete

  19. Dear,
    friends........
    I read your blog, its really awesome,
    I am seeing that you are selling home. I have also a site related to you.
    This has helped Union Township to hold it's value very well over the slower real estate market.
    This town is a safe investment for anyone who wants a great investment property or a great place to live for yourself.
    Newark Investment Properties For Sale

    Regards,
    Rasel

    ReplyDelete
  20. Want to know the best way to find a buyer for your property? What type of advertising works best? How much should you spend advertising a home for sale?See more at-houses for sale in newark

    ReplyDelete
  21. I'm not sure where you are getting your info, but good topic. I needs to spend some time to know more or understanding more. Thanks for great information I was looking for this information for my mission.
    Solar PV

    ReplyDelete

  22. Hi admin
    Its extremely impressive, that is the diary you admire I likable it.
    I have also this related site.
    A good Real Estate Investor has an arsenal of strategies for buying houses.
    The investor has to know how they plan to exit the property when they buy it, so that requires either some equity or some other value.
    houses for sale newark

    Regards,
    osmanguni

    ReplyDelete
  23. thanks for sharing this information..i find it very interesting..

    Solar Las Vegas

    ReplyDelete
  24. Thanks for the good writeup. It in truth was once a leisure account it.
    Glance complicated to far added agreeable from you! However, how can we keep in touch? Solar rooftop

    ReplyDelete
  25. Nice stuff dear. I really like your post and agree with your point related price between china and American company. I always suggest to all, go with trusted and well services provided company. If you are looking for Solar panel installation company & Residential solar financing companies Australia. Click on it and read it.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Wow i can say that this is another great article as expected of this blog.Bookmarked this site.. Josh Greenway

    ReplyDelete
  27. Your Blog shares a valuable information about #RenewableEnergy. It is very helpfull to design the solar plant. Solar energy is a Renewable resource that is not only sustainable for energy consumption. Solar power can be used to generate electricity, it is also used to heat water. Solar panels requires little maintenance. After installation and optimization they are very reliable due to the fact that they actively create electricity in just a few millimeters and do not require any type of mechanical parts that can fail. Solar panels produce energy very silent. The federal government has also introduced generous tax credits for individuals and companies that invest in solar and other natural energy resources.we are one of the top most Solar power plant designing consultants in the world.we provide services like Power Plant Designing, DPR Preparation, Turnkey Solutions, Cost Benefit Analysis, etc, ....If you have any queries, Click on Solar plant Designing <\a>

    ReplyDelete
  28. Your blogs and accumulation attracts me to arrive rearward again n again.thimfilmsolarhome

    ReplyDelete
  29. Hi admin,
    I read your blog, its really awesome,

    The rental housing supply is not keeping up with the demand. Affordability is an issue that will be exacerbated by growing demand. The concern is that apartments and houses for rent absorb more than thirty percent of a renter's income.

    rental properties


    Your regards
    mowley akter

    ReplyDelete